website Skip to content
Affinito Black Week is coming · Up to 50% off selected items
EnglishEnglish
  • Language ItalianoItaliano
  • Language EnglishEnglish
  • Language DeutschDeutsch
  • Language FrançaisFrançais
  • Language EspañolEspañol
USD $
  • ALL L
  • BAM КМ
  • CAD $
  • CHF CHF
  • CZK Kč
  • DKK kr.
  • EUR €
  • GBP £
  • HUF Ft
  • ISK kr
  • MDL L
  • MKD ден
  • PLN zł
  • RON Lei
  • RSD РСД
  • SEK kr
  • UAH ₴
  • USD $
info@affinitocamiceria.it   |   WhatsApp 351 085 4633

What are you looking for?

Why men's shirt buttons are on the right and women's are on the left

Why men's shirt buttons are on the right and women's are on the left

Why men's shirt buttons are on the right and women's are on the left

Try an experiment the next time you're in front of the wardrobe: take one of your shirts and a women's shirt, hold them side by side, and look at where the buttons are. On a men's shirt, the buttons are sewn on the right side and the buttonholes on the left, so the left flap overlaps the right. On a women's shirt, exactly the opposite happens. It's a convention so deeply rooted that we take it for granted, yet why men's shirt buttons are on the right and women's are on the left remains, even today, one of the small unanswered questions of costume history. There is no document, no edict, or tailor who established the rule: instead, there are several theories, some plausible, others decidedly closer to legend. Let's look at them together, with a bit of critical spirit.

First of all: what exactly are we talking about

When people talk about "buttons on the right," they mean the side on which the button is sewn, looking at the shirt while it's worn. For someone wearing a men's shirt, the right hand holds the button in place and the left hand brings the buttonhole over it: the left flap ends on top, the right underneath. On women's garments, however, it's the right flap that overlaps. The same rule, of course, doesn't apply only to shirts: you'll find it on jackets, coats, vests, and cardigans.

An important detail before getting into the theories: for much of history, buttons were a precious object. For centuries, garments were fastened with laces, pins, buckles, and hooks, while buttons as we know them today, with buttonholes, spread through Europe starting in the late Middle Ages and remained a sign of wealth for a long time. This helps us understand why many explanations revolve around the lives of the wealthier classes.

The sword theory: men's shirt buttons and the right hand

It's probably the most cited explanation. For centuries, men of rank wore their sword on their left hip, so they could draw it with their right hand, given that the vast majority of people are right-handed. If the jacket or overcoat fastens with the left flap over the right, the right hand crossing the body to grab the hilt does not risk getting caught in the opening of the garment. In fact, it can easily slip between the flaps, perhaps to warm up or to reach something stored inside.

A variant of this idea concerns armor and combat: an overlapping opening from left to right would offer less purchase for the blade or spear of a right-handed opponent. It's a compelling argument, but it must be said honestly that there is no direct evidence that the tailors of the time reasoned this way. It's a "functional" explanation reconstructed after the fact, consistent but not proven.

The maid theory: ladies did not dress themselves

The second most widespread theory concerns women's clothing. Women of the wealthier classes, between the 17th and 18th centuries, wore complex dresses with corsets, petticoats, rows of tiny buttons, and lacing at the back. They did not dress themselves: their personal maids did. A right-handed maid, standing in front of her lady, would have found it more convenient to button a garment with buttons on the left side of the wearer, i.e., on her own right.

Men, on the contrary, generally dressed themselves, even when they had a valet, and therefore their garments would have remained "designed" for those who button with their right hand. In favor of this hypothesis is the fact that buttons, being expensive, appeared mainly on the clothes of those who could afford a servant. When women's clothing then spread to all social classes, the convention would have remained out of pure habit. Here too, however, we are talking about a hypothesis: plausible, widely repeated, never documented with certainty.

Horses, babies, and other practical explanations

There are also a series of theories that link the side of the buttons to everyday actions. Here's a summary:

  • Side-saddle riding. Women rode horses sitting sideways, with their legs on the animal's left side and the right side of their body facing forward. An opening fastened with the right flap over the left would have prevented the wind from getting into the dress during the ride.
  • Breastfeeding. Many mothers hold the baby with their left arm, leaving the right free. An opening with buttons on the left would have made it easier to unbutton the bodice with the free hand.
  • Social distinction. According to some costume historians, the difference simply arose to clearly distinguish men's clothing from women's, in an era when roles were rigidly separated.

Each of these explanations has its own logic, but none is sufficient on its own. It is likely that the truth, if we ever know it, is a combination of multiple factors, consolidated by centuries of sartorial habit.

The legend of Napoleon

The most colorful story couldn't be missing. It is said that Napoleon Bonaparte, famous for his pose with his hand tucked into his waistcoat, was annoyed by the ladies who imitated him mockingly, and that for this reason he ordered the side of the buttons on women's dresses to be reversed, making that gesture impossible. It's a funny anecdote, but it is considered entirely implausible by scholars: there is no trace of such an order, and "reverse" buttons on women's garments are documented even before him. Take it for what it is: a nice legend to tell at the dinner table.

Curiously, Napoleon's name also appears in another button-related legend, that of the buttons on military jacket sleeves, which were supposedly intended to prevent soldiers from wiping their noses on their sleeves. This too, like the previous one, belongs more to folklore than to documented history.

Why the rule has survived to this day

If the original reasons are uncertain, it is much clearer why the convention has reached us. With the industrial production of the 19th and 20th centuries, manufacturers standardized models, patterns, and sewing lines. At that point, changing the side would have meant revising processes, machinery, and customer habits, without any concrete advantage. Sartorial tradition, moreover, is by nature conservative: a shirtmaker learns to assemble a garment in a certain way and passes it down.

There is also an element of recognizability. For decades, the side of the buttons allowed you to tell at a glance whether a garment had been designed for a man or a woman, even when the cuts were similar. Today, with fashion playing more and more with genderless garments, some brands choose one closure or the other freely, but in classic men's shirtmaking, the rule remains firm: buttons on the right, buttonholes on the left, left flap on top.

A detail that says a lot

In the end, the charm of this curiosity lies precisely in the fact that it has no definitive answer. Every time you button your shirt in the morning, you repeat a gesture that carries centuries of history: swordsmen, ladies with their servants, horsewomen, tailors who passed down a rule without asking where it came from. It is one of those details that make a shirt much more than a simple piece of clothing.

If you like these little stories, you can find other insights on shirt culture on our blog. And if you want to see firsthand how tradition translates into details, take a look at Affinito shirts: in our stores and online you will find garments where every button, on the right as the rule dictates, is in its place for a good reason, even when that reason has been lost in history.

Affinito Shirt Stores

You can try on the shirts, request custom tailoring, and see the embroidery in person at all our stores:

  • Afragola (NA): Via Alcide De Gasperi, 66
  • Afragola (NA): Le Porte di Napoli Shopping Center, Via Santa Maria la Nova, 1
  • Casalnuovo di Napoli (NA): Via Lagno, 7
  • Frattamaggiore (NA): Piazza Riscatto, 28
  • Nola (NA): Corso Tommaso Vitale, 113
  • Nola (NA): Via San Felice, 62
  • Quarto (NA): Via Masullo, 76
  • Empoli (FI): Via Raffaello Sanzio, 199
  • Bologna: Centronova Shopping Center
  • Mondovì (CN): Mondovicino Shopping Center & Retail Park

See all stores on the map